Math Proofs, Explained Visually

Lune of Hippocrates: 2 Curved Moons = 1 Triangle

A right triangle (6, 8, 10) with a half circle on each side: the two pink moons together equal the triangle's area — 24, no π!

Ages 12–15 · US Grade 7–8 2:49

Step by step

  1. Two pink moons = the triangle? No π needed!
    These two pink moons, added together, have exactly the same area as the triangle. Curved shapes, and no pi needed!
  2. Square corner · sides 6, 8, 10 · a half circle on each side
    The triangle has a square corner, and sides six, eight, and ten. Each side has a half circle on it. The moons are the parts of the small half circles outside the big one.
  3. Way 1: each half circle's area · first, the one on side 6
    Way one: find each half circle's area. Start with the one on the side of six.
  4. Radius = 6 ÷ 2 = 3 · whole circle: π × 3² = 9π
    Its radius is half of six: three. A whole circle with radius three would be pi times three squared: nine pi.
  5. Half circle: 9π ÷ 2 = 4.5π
    Our shape is only half of that circle. So it's nine pi divided by two: four and a half pi.
  6. Side 8: r = 4 → 16π ÷ 2 = 8π · side 10: r = 5 → 25π ÷ 2 = 12.5π
    The same way, the half circle on eight has radius four: sixteen pi, halved, is eight pi. The big one on ten has radius five: twenty-five pi, halved, is twelve and a half pi.
  7. 4.5π + 8π = 12.5π → small + small = big
    Now add the two small ones: four and a half pi plus eight pi is twelve and a half pi. Exactly the big one!
  8. Small half circles = moons + 2 slivers
    Now look at the pieces. The small half circles are the moons plus two thin purple slivers.
  9. Big half circle = triangle + the same 2 slivers
    The big half circle is the triangle plus the same two slivers.
  10. Take away the slivers → moons = triangle
    Take the same slivers away from both. What's left must be equal: the two moons equal the triangle!
  11. Triangle = 6 × 8 ÷ 2 = 24 → moons = 24
    The triangle is six times eight, divided by two: twenty-four. So the moons are twenty-four too.
  12. Hippocrates of Chios (Greece, ~440 BC): the first curved area found exactly
    About twenty-four hundred years ago, Hippocrates of Chios in Greece found the area of a moon like this. It was the first curved shape anyone measured exactly.
  13. Right triangle: the two moons = the triangle
    So on any right triangle, the two moons together always equal the triangle.
  14. On a test: half circle = π(d ÷ 2)² ÷ 2 = πd² ÷ 8 → small + small = big → moons = triangle = 24
    On a test, write the proof like this. A half circle is pi times half the width, squared, divided by two. Half the width, squared, is the width squared over four. Halve it again: over eight. Add the two small half circles: six squared plus eight squared is ten squared, so together they equal the big one. Both pictures hold the same slivers. Take them away: the moons equal the triangle, and the triangle is twenty-four.

Your turn

Your turn: a leaf. Two quarter circles in a ten-by-ten square overlap in this leaf. Use three point one four for pi. What's the leaf's area?

Show the answer

Each quarter circle has radius ten, the side of the square. It's a quarter of pi r squared: three point one four times one hundred, divided by four, is seventy-eight point five. Two of them make one fifty-seven. The square is ten times ten: one hundred. The two quarter circles cover the whole square, and the leaf twice. So the leaf is one fifty-seven minus one hundred: about fifty-seven!

Keep going

There are more short lessons on this topic, each with a full write-up.

All Math Proofs, Explained Visually lessons See where this fits on the roadmap

More in Math Proofs, Explained Visually